[0001] 1. Field of the Invention
[0002] This invention broadly relates to methods and apparatus for making orthodontic appliances such as brackets and buccal tubes. More particularly, the present invention concerns orthodontic appliances having a bonding surface for attachment to a tooth, and the bonding surface is shaped as desired in accordance with the selected treatment objectives. The present invention also concerns indirect bonding transfer apparatus that includes one or more appliances having a contoured bonding surface.
[0003] 2. Description of the Related Art
[0004] Orthodontic treatment involves movement of malpositioned teeth to desired locations in the oral cavity. Orthodontic treatment can improve the patient's facial appearance, especially in instances where the teeth are noticeably crooked or where the jaws are out of alignment with each other. Orthodontic treatment can also enhance the function of the teeth by providing better occlusion while eating.
[0005] One common type of orthodontic treatment involves the use of tiny, slotted appliances known as brackets. The brackets are fixed to the patient's teeth and an archwire is placed in the slot of each bracket. The archwire forms a track to guide movement of teeth to desired locations.
[0006] The ends of orthodontic archwires are often connected to small appliances known as buccal tubes that are, in turn, secured to the patient's molar teeth. In many instances, a set of brackets, buccal tubes and an archwire is provided for each of the patient's upper and lower dental arches. The brackets, buccal tubes and archwires are commonly referred to collectively as “braces”.
[0007] In the past, metallic orthodontic appliances including brackets and buccal tubes were often welded to bands. Each band was adapted to encircle one of the patient's teeth and provide a secure connection between the tooth and the appliance. Typically, a composition such as a band cement was applied to the inner surface of the band before placement on the tooth in order to fill any gaps or voids between the band and the tooth enamel and help prevent the band from “rocking” on the tooth.
[0008] However, metallic bands are generally considered unaesthetic and contribute to an undesirable “metallic mouth” appearance. Moreover, for a proper fit, each band must be carefully selected so that its size and shape match the size and shape of the patient's tooth. Additionally, bands are not considered suitable for use with appliances made of non-metallic materials, such as ceramic and plastic.
[0009] In recent years, there has been great interest in the use of appliances that are bonded to the enamel surface of the teeth by an adhesive. These appliances are not mounted on metallic bands and consequently the patient's appearance is improved. In addition, the expense of the bands, as well as the time needed to select the bands and attach the appliances to the bands, can be avoided.
[0010] However, it is important that any appliance that is adhesively bonded to a tooth remain firmly attached to the tooth over the entire course of treatment. Orthodontic appliances are sometimes subject to significant forces in the oral cavity due to the presence of a food object that may be located between the appliances and the teeth during mastication. These forces can be relatively large when the patient is chewing a relatively hard food object such hard candy or ice, and may in some instances cause the appliance to debond from the tooth.
[0011] Unfortunately, the progress of the orthodontic treatment program can come to an abrupt halt when an orthodontic appliance unintentionally debonds from a tooth. In that event, the patient should immediately return to the practitioner for re-attachment or replacement of the appliance so that treatment can resume. The time and expense of both the practitioner and the patient that is incurred to respond to a spontaneously debonded appliance is considered a nuisance that is best avoided.
[0012] As a result, manufacturers of orthodontic appliances often go to great lengths to ensure that their appliances remain firmly adhered to the teeth over the entire course of treatment. To this end, the base of the appliances is often provided with features to improve the strength of the bond between the appliance and the tooth. As one example, the base may have a concave, compound contour that closely matches the convex, compound surface of the tooth so that a mating fit is obtained. As another example, the base may include mechanical or chemical features such as projections, recesses or chemical treatments that serve to enhance the strength of the bond between the adhesive and the appliance. However, appliances are typically manufactured and sold with bases having a shape that matches the expected shape of a statistical “average” patient, which may or may not be similar in shape to the tooth of the particular patient undergoing treatment.
[0013] In addition, in many types of orthodontic techniques, the shape of the appliance base is an important factor for helping to ensure that the teeth move to their intended final positions. For example, one common type of orthodontic treatment technique is known as the “straight-wire” technique, where the resilient archwire tends to follow a smooth curve that lies in a horizontal plane at the conclusion of treatment. If, for instance, the convex shape of the patient's tooth is oriented in a direction that is different than the orientation of the concave shape of an appliance made for an “average” patient, the appliance will not be properly oriented to the tooth and the archwire slot will extend at an improper angle relative to the tooth for straight-wire treatment. As the archwire assumes a level, straight configuration near the end of the treatment program, the improperly oriented appliance will cause the tooth to assume a corresponding, improper position.
[0014] Other aspects of the shape of the appliance base are also important. For example, it may be desirable to provide a base having a “wedge-shaped” configuration, so that the long axis of the tooth is pivoted or tipped toward a certain pre-selected orientation as the archwire assumes the configuration of a smooth, horizontal curve near the end of the treatment program. In this regard, it is possible to orient the shape of the wedge so that the tooth is pivoted in a rotational direction about its long axis, or alternatively so that the long axis of the tooth is tipped along either a mesial-distal reference axis or a labial-lingual reference axis.
[0015] In general, orthodontic appliances that are adapted to be adhesively bonded to the patient's teeth are placed on the teeth by either one of two methods: a direct bonding method, or an indirect bonding method. In the direct bonding method, the appliance and adhesive are grasped with a pair of tweezers or other hand instrument and placed by the practitioner on the surface of the tooth in an approximate desired location. Next, the appliance is shifted along the surface of the tooth as needed until the practitioner is satisfied with its position. Once the appliance is in its precise, intended location, the appliance is pressed firmly onto the tooth to seat the appliance in the adhesive. Excess adhesive in areas adjacent the base of the appliance is removed, and the adhesive is then allowed to cure and fix the appliance firmly in place. Typical adhesives include light-curable adhesives that begin to harden upon exposure to actinic radiation, and two-component chemical-cure adhesives that begin to harden when the components are mixed together.
[0016] While the direct bonding technique described above is in widespread use and is considered satisfactory by many, there are shortcomings that are inherent with such a technique. For example, access to surfaces of malposed teeth may be difficult. In some instances, and particularly in connection with posterior teeth, the practitioner may have difficulty seeing the precise position of the bracket relative to the tooth surface. Additionally, the appliance may be unintentionally bumped from its intended location during the time that the excess adhesive is being removed adjacent the base of the appliance.
[0017] Another problem associated with the direct bonding technique described above concerns the significant length of time needed to carry out the procedure of bonding each appliance to each individual tooth. Typically, the practitioner will attempt to ensure that each appliance is positioned in its precise, intended location before the adhesive is cured, and some time may be necessary before the practitioner is satisfied with the location of each appliance. At the same time, however, the patient may experience discomfort and have difficulty in remaining relatively motionless, especially if the patient is an adolescent. As can be appreciated, there are aspects of the direct bonding technique that can be considered a nuisance for both the practitioner and for the patient.
[0018] Indirect bonding techniques often avoid many of the problems noted above. In general, indirect bonding techniques known in the past have involved the use of a transfer tray having a shape that matches the configuration of at least part of a patient's dental arch. A set of appliances such as brackets are releasably connected to the tray at certain, predetermined locations. Adhesive is applied to the base of each appliance, and the tray is then placed over the patient's teeth until such time as the adhesive hardens. Next, the tray is detached from the teeth as well as from the appliances, with the result that all of the appliances previously connected to the tray are now bonded to the respective teeth at their intended, predetermined locations.
[0019] In more detail, one method of indirect bonding of orthodontic appliances includes the steps of taking an impression of each of the patient's dental arches and then making a replica plaster or “stone” model from each impression. Optionally, a soap solution (such as Model Glow brand solution from Whip Mix Corporation) or wax is applied to the stone model. A separation solution (such as COE-SEP brand tinfoil substitute from GC America, Inc.) is then applied to the stone model and allowed to dry. If desired, the teeth of the model can be marked with a pencil to assist in placing the brackets in ideal positions.
[0020] Next, the brackets are bonded to the stone models. Optionally, the bonding adhesive can be a chemical curing adhesive (such as Concise brand adhesive from 3M) or a light-curable adhesive (such as Transbond XT brand adhesive or Transbond LR brand adhesive, from 3M). Optionally, the brackets may be adhesive precoated brackets such as those described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,015,180, 5,172,809, 5,354,199 and 5,429,299.
[0021] A transfer tray is then made by placing a matrix material over the model as well as over the brackets placed on the model. For example, a plastic sheet matrix material may be held by a frame and exposed to radiant heat. Once the plastic sheet material has softened, it is placed over the model and the brackets. Air in the space between the sheet material and the model is then evacuated, and the plastic sheet material assumes a configuration that precisely matches the shape of the replica teeth of the stone model and the attached brackets.
[0022] The plastic material is then allowed to cool and harden to form a tray. The tray and the brackets (which are embedded in an interior wall of the tray) are then detached from the stone model and sides of the tray are trimmed as may be desired. Typically, the adhesive that previously attached the brackets to the stone models remains connected to the brackets. This adhesive has an outer surface that subsequently provides a bonding surface for attaching the brackets to the patient's teeth in the oral cavity. In some instances, this bonding surface will have a contoured shape that roughly matches the shape of the replica tooth structure as well as the patient's tooth structure.
[0023] Once the patient has returned to the office, a quantity of adhesive is placed on the base of bracket, and the tray with the embedded brackets is then placed over the matching portions of the patient's dental arch. Since the configuration of the interior of the tray closely matches the respective portions of the patient's dental arch, each bracket is ultimately positioned on the patient's teeth at precisely the same location that corresponds to the previous location of the same bracket on the stone model.
[0024] Both light-curable adhesives and chemical curing adhesives have been used in the past in indirect bonding techniques to secure the brackets to the patient's teeth. If a light-curable adhesive is used, the tray is preferably transparent or translucent. If a two-component chemical curing adhesive is used, the components can be mixed together immediately before application of the adhesive to the brackets. Alternatively, one component may be placed on each bracket base and the other component may be placed on the tooth surface. In either case, placing of the tray with the embedded brackets on corresponding portions of the patient's dental arch enables the brackets to be bonded to the teeth as a group using only a short amount of time that the patient is occupying the chair in the operatory. With such a technique, individual placement and positioning of each bracket in seriatim fashion on the teeth is avoided.
[0025] A variety of transfer trays and materials for transfer trays have been proposed in the past. For example, some practitioners use a soft sheet material (such as Bioplast tray material from Scheu-Dental GmbH) for placement over the stone model and the appliances on the model. A vacuum is applied to draw the soft material into intimate contact with the model and the appliances on the model. Next, a stiffer sheet material (such as Biocryl sheet material, from Scheu-Dental GmbH or Great Lakes Orthodontics, Ltd.) is formed over the softer sheet material, again using a vacuum forming technique. The stiffer material provides a backbone to the tray, while the softer material initially holds the appliances and yet is sufficiently flexible to release from the appliances after the appliances have been fixed to the patient's teeth.
[0026] It has also been proposed in the past to use a silicone impression material or a bite registration material (such as Memosil 2, from Heraeus-Kulzer GmbH & Co. KG). The silicone material is applied over the appliances that are attached to the study model so that the appliances are partially encapsulated.
[0027] In an article entitled “
[0028] Indirect bonding techniques offer a number of advantages over direct bonding techniques. For one thing, and as indicated above, it is possible to bond a plurality of brackets to a patient's dental arch simultaneously, thereby avoiding the need to bond each appliance in individual fashion. In addition, the indirect bonding tray helps to locate all of the brackets in their proper, intended positions such that adjustment of each bracket on the surface of the tooth before bonding is avoided. The increased placement accuracy of the appliances that is often afforded by indirect bonding techniques helps ensure that the patient's teeth are moved to their proper, intended positions at the conclusion of treatment.
[0029] While the indirect bonding techniques as described above have proven satisfactory for many practitioners, there is a continuing need to improve the state of the art. Moreover, there is a need to improve methods and apparatus for providing an appliance with a bonding surface that is especially adapted for the particular patient at hand.
[0030] The present invention relates to an orthodontic appliance with an improved bonding surface as well as methods and apparatus for making the same. The bonding surface of the present invention is made of a light-curable composition that is cured to a relatively hard condition simultaneously across its entire extent, even when the appliance is made of a material that is opaque to the transmission of actinic radiation. In addition, the bonding surface is relatively smooth, even in regions near the center of the appliance base. As a result, a bonding surface having a precise, mating fit with the shape of the patient's tooth structure is readily achieved.
[0031] The present invention is carried out by use of a model that transmits actinic radiation. Some of the actinic radiation that passes through the model will reach portions of the light-curable composition that are located near the center of the appliance base. Those portions are hardened to substantially the same extent as remaining portions of the light-curable composition. Consequently, the shape of those central portions is not disturbed as the appliance is detached from the replica, and the bonding surface has a configuration that precisely matches the shape of the tooth.
[0032] In more detail, the present invention in one aspect relates to a method of making a bonding surface for an orthodontic appliance comprising:
[0033] providing a replica of a patient's tooth structure, wherein the replica is comprised of a material that transmits actinic radiation;
[0034] placing a photocurable composition on the base of at least one orthodontic appliance;
[0035] engaging the photocurable composition of each appliance with the replica tooth structure; and
[0036] directing actinic radiation to the photocurable composition, wherein the act of directing actinic radiation to the photocurable composition is carried out by directing at least a portion of the actinic radiation through the replica tooth structure.
[0037] The present invention is also directed in another aspect to a method of making orthodontic transfer apparatus for indirect bonding. This method comprises:
[0038] making a replica of a patient's tooth structure, wherein the replica is comprised of a material that transmits actinic radiation;
[0039] placing a photocurable composition on the base of at least one orthodontic appliance;
[0040] engaging the photocurable composition of each appliance with the replica tooth structure;
[0041] directing actinic radiation to the photocurable composition, wherein the act of directing actinic radiation to the photocurable composition is carried out at least in part by directing actinic radiation through the replica of the patient's tooth structure; and
[0042] forming a transfer apparatus over each appliance and the replica tooth structure.
[0043] The present invention is also directed to an apparatus for making a bonding surface for an orthodontic appliance. The apparatus comprises a replica of tooth structure, wherein the replica is made of a material that transmits actinic radiation. The apparatus also includes an orthodontic appliance and a photocurable composition between the appliance and the replica. The apparatus additionally includes a source of actinic radiation that is operable to direct at least a portion of the actinic radiation along a path through the replica and toward the photocurable composition.
[0044] These and other aspects of the invention are described in more detail below and are illustrated in the accompanying drawings.
[0045]
[0046]
[0047]
[0048]
[0049]
[0050]
[0051]
[0052]
[0053]
[0054]
[0055]
[0056] A method for indirect bonding of one or more orthodontic appliances in accordance with one aspect of the present invention will first be described.
[0057] Optionally, the replica
[0058] The model or replica
[0059] The replica
[0060] Care is taken during making of the replica
[0061] As an alternative, the replica
[0062] The replica
[0063] Preferably, the replica
[0064] Next, and as shown in
[0065] As an alternative to segments of spacer material
[0066] In this embodiment, the spacer material also includes a sheet of spacer material
[0067] As another alternative, the spacer material
[0068] The spacer material
[0069] Next, a vacuum is applied to the replica
[0070] Subsequently, a tray
[0071] Once the tray
[0072] A thin layer of a release agent is then applied to the replica
[0073] Next, a determination is made of the proper intended position of each appliance on the replica teeth
[0074] For example, and for the replica
[0075] Next, orthodontic appliances
[0076] Preferably, the appliances
[0077] If the appliances
[0078] Once the appliances
[0079] Next, the practitioner applies firm pressure to each appliance
[0080] The adhesive is designated by the numeral
[0081] Once the accuracy of the appliance position has been confirmed, a source of actinic radiation is activated in order to direct actinic radiation toward the adhesive
[0082] An example of a suitable curing chamber is the Triad 2000 brand visible light curing system from Dentsply. Preferably, the curing chamber is sufficiently large to contain a number of replicas
[0083] If the appliances
[0084] The use of transparent or translucent materials to make the replica
[0085] Actinic radiation passing through the replica
[0086] Additionally, the replica
[0087] The appliances
[0088] Optionally, the path of movement of the robotic arm and the ultimate position of the placed appliance
[0089] Preferably, the software includes subprograms for selecting appliances, analyzing malocclusions and/or predicting tooth movement and final positions of the teeth. An example of software for choosing appliances is described in pending U.S. patent application Ser. No. 10/081,220 entitled “Selection of Orthodontic Brackets”, the disclosure of which is expressly incorporated by reference herein. Optionally, the software includes subprograms for making custom orthodontic appliances using, for example, a computer numerical control milling machine, instead of selecting appliances from an existing set of appliances as mentioned above.
[0090] As an additional option, an orthodontic archwire may be placed in the slots of the appliances
[0091] The replica
[0092] Subsequently, the model
[0093] Preferably, the matrix material has a relatively low viscosity before hardening so that intimate contact between the matrix material
[0094] Alternatively, the matrix material
[0095] Once the matrix material
[0096] Once the patient has returned to the office, the patient's teeth that are to receive appliances are isolated using cheek retractors, tongue guards, cotton rolls, dry angles and/or other articles as needed. The teeth are then thoroughly dried using pressurized air from an air syringe. Etching solution (such as 3M Unitek Transbond XT brand etching gel) is then dabbed onto the teeth in the general area that is to be covered by the appliances
[0097] After the etching solution has remained on the selected tooth surfaces for a period of approximately 30 seconds, the solution is rinsed away from the teeth with a stream of water for 15 seconds. The patient's teeth are then dried by the application of pressurized air from an air syringe (for example, for a time period of 30 seconds) and excess water is removed by suction. Care should also be undertaken to ensure that the saliva does not come in contact with the etched enamel surfaces. Cotton rolls and other absorbent devices are replaced as needed, again making sure that saliva does not contact the etched enamel. Air from the air syringe may then be applied to the teeth again to ensure that the teeth are thoroughly dried.
[0098] Next, a bonding adhesive is applied to the hardened adhesive
[0099] After the first component
[0100] Other examples of suitable two-component chemical curing adhesives include Sondhi brand Rapid-Set indirect bonding adhesive, Unite brand adhesive and Concise brand adhesive, all from 3M Unitek. Alternatively, a resin-modified glass ionomer cement may be employed.
[0101] Once the bonding adhesive has hardened, the tray
[0102] As another option, the tray
[0103] Once the matrix material
[0104] As can be appreciated, the hardened adhesive
[0105] The light-transmitting replica
[0106] The replica
[0107] The use of the light-transmitting replica
[0108] In addition, the unhardened portions found when using an opaque replica as mentioned above may also pull away from adjacent areas of the appliance base as the appliance is detached from the replica. Those portions, even when later hardened under the influence of ambient light, may weaken the bond between the hardened adhesive and the appliance and facilitate unintentional detachment of the appliance during the course of treatment.
[0109] Also, it has been observed that such unhardened portions present a cloudy appearance, in contrast to the relatively clear appearance of adjacent, hardened portions. It is believed that the cloudy appearance is due to the increased surface roughness of the unhardened portions, as well as to detachment of the adhesive from the appliance base. The cloudy, unhardened portions together with the clear, hardened portions tend to present a somewhat unsightly spotted appearance that is not eliminated even after the unhardened portions cure under the influence of ambient light.
[0110] The use of the spacer material
[0111] Moreover, the use of the spacer material
[0112] Another advantage of the present invention is that the relatively soft matrix material
[0113] The matrix material
[0114] Furthermore, the use of the spacer material
[0115] A transfer apparatus
[0116] The transfer apparatus
[0117] The tubing
[0118] Preferably, a channel or passage
[0119] The outlet
[0120] The vacuum is applied to the outlet
[0121] A transfer apparatus
[0122] The transfer apparatus
[0123] The bladder(s)
[0124] In the illustrated example, a bladder
[0125] However, the concepts exemplified in
[0126] In the embodiments of
[0127] A transfer apparatus
[0128] The transfer apparatus
[0129] The cord
[0130] In the embodiment shown in
[0131] A variety of other embodiments are also possible and will be apparent to those skilled in the art. For example, in the embodiments shown in
[0132] As another option, the transfer apparatus described in the various embodiments above may be used for bonding appliances such as brackets, tubes and lingual sheaths to the lingual surfaces of the patient's teeth. In that instance, the bladders and cords, if utilized, are adapted and modified as needed.
[0133] Additionally, the transfer apparatus may be used for bonding only a single appliance to a patient's tooth. For example, a portion of the transfer apparatus described above may be used to bond a single appliance to a single tooth subsequent to the time that other appliances are bonded, such as in instances where access to the tooth is initially hindered by other teeth. As another example, a portion of the transfer apparatus described above may be used to re-bond an appliance that has unintentionally debonded from the tooth, or to bond a new appliance to a tooth to replace the original appliance.
[0134] A number of other variations, modifications and additions are also possible without departing from the spirit of the invention. Accordingly, the invention should not be deemed limited to the specific embodiments described above, but instead only by a fair scope of the claims and their equivalents.
[0135] A test was conducted to compare the surface roughness of a sample of hardened modeling stone to the surface roughness of a sample of hardened epoxy resin. A stone sample was made by preparing a quantity of Quickstone brand laboratory stone (from Whip Mix Corporation) according to the manufacturer's directions. The stone preparation was then placed in a recess of a polypropylene substrate and allowed to harden.
[0136] A surface roughness tester (model no. SJ-301, from Mitutoyo Corporation, Kanagawa, Japan) was used at five distinct locations of the hardened stone to determine surface roughness. At the five locations, the hardened stone had an average surface roughness of 53.16 micro-inch (microinch Ra), with a standard deviation of 4.22.
[0137] The surface roughness test was repeated as described above, except that epoxy was used instead of modeling stone. The epoxy was the E-CAST F-82 resin and No. 302 hardener, from United Resin Corporation, as described above. At five locations, the hardened epoxy had an average surface roughness of 11.12 micro-inch, with a standard deviation of 0.93.
[0138] The surface roughness test was again repeated to determine the surface roughness of the polypropylene substrate. At five locations, the substrate had an average surface roughness of 9.7 micro-inch, with a standard deviation of 1.64.
[0139] The data show that the epoxy exhibited a roughness very similar to the roughness of the casting surface (i.e. the polypropylene substrate), while the stone exhibited a surface roughness that was significantly higher. Consequently, the epoxy material assumed a configuration during casting that closely resembled the surface of the casting surface, while the stone assumed a configuration during casting that was significantly rougher in texture.