Next Patent: Measurement and correction of a scan line length error
Next Patent: Measurement and correction of a scan line length error
Plaque It!
Sponsored by: Flash of Genius |
[0001] This application is based on U.S. Application Serial No. 60/306,578, filed Jul. 18, 2001.
[0003] This invention relates to the field of scanning probe devices. More particularly, the invention relates to improvements in an atomic force microscope used to measure the deflections of a cantilever.
[0004] Scanning probe devices, such as the atomic force microscope (AFM) have proven to be excellent tools for imaging a wide range of materials such as metals, semiconductors, minerals, polymers, and biomaterials. In an AFM, forces are measured by means of a cantilever that deflects when forces act on it. The deflection of the cantilever is sensed by a detection system, commonly by focusing an incident beam as a spot onto the cantilever and directing the reflected beam onto a segmented detector. Specialized AFMs called “force pullers” have been built for the purpose of pulling on molecules to determine the structure and dynamics of those molecules. AFM-like cantilevers and cantilever arrays have also been used recently as chemical sensing devices. In this mode of operation, a chemically sensitive layer is applied to one of more surfaces of the cantilever. When a target molecule is detected, the cantilever's nanomechanical properties are affected—i.e., the deflection and/or resonant frequency of the cantilever will change.
[0005] Since its introduction, the AFM and cantilever sensing devices have become increasingly more advanced, measuring decreasingly smaller forces and utilizing decreasingly smaller cantilevers. This has introduced problems relating to the sensitivity of the instrument. There is a need to provide greater sensitivity and a smaller spot size to accommodate the smaller cantilevers and smaller forces that scientific investigators need to either measure samples or manipulate them. Similar detection techniques are also used to monitor the motion of the optical probes used in Near-Field Scanning Optical Microscopes (NSOM), the scanning ion-conductance microscope (SICM), and a variety of other scanning probe microscopes. The growing field of nanotechnology also provides ample motivation for the precision measurement of the position and/or motion of a wide variety of objects down to the nanometer scale and below.
[0006] The following U.S. patents are relevant to this invention: U.S. Pat. No. 5,825,020-Atomic force microscope for generating a small incident beam spot, U.S. Pat. No. RE 034489-Atomic force microscope with optional replaceable fluid cell, and U.S. Pat. No. 4,800,274-High resolution atomic force microscope. The following publications are relevant to this invention: (1) Mario B. Viani, et al., “Small cantilevers for force spectroscopy of single molecules;” Journal of Applied Physics, Volume 86, Number 4, pp. 2258-2262. (2) Tilman E. Schaffer, et al., “Characterization and optimization of the detection sensitivity of an atomic force microscope for small cantilevers;” Journal of Applied Physics, Volume 84, Number 9, pp. 4661-4666. (3) Tilman E. Schaffer, et al., “An atomic force microscope for small cantilevers;” SPIE—The International Society for Optical Engineering, Volume 3009, pp. 48-52. (4) D. A. Walters, et al., “Short cantilevers for atomic force microscopy;” Review of Scientific Instrumentation, Volume 67, Number 10, pp. 3583-3590. (5) T. E. Schaffer, et al, “Studies of vibrating atomic force microscope cantilevers in liquid;” Journal of Applied Physics, Volume 80, Number 7, pp. 3622-3627. (6) Deron A. Walters, et al, “Atomic force microscopy using small cantilevers;” SPIE—The International Society for Optical Engineering, Volume 3009, pp. 43-47. The foregoing patents and publications are all incorporated herein by reference.
[0007] The present invention provides improvements for the optical tracking and detection of reflected light beams that has general application to any optical system for measuring the motion of a cantilever, and specific application to AFMs. In particular, the present invention provides an improved AFM head that has significant novel features and advantages over existing AFM heads. A particular novel feature is the use of a novel optical path wherein different regions of an objective lens are used for incident and reflected light. A second novel feature of this AFM is the unified optics block that contains all the optical elements of the optical lever detection system between and encompassing the light source and the final focusing lens in an extremely small and rigid package. Another novel feature is that the beam from the AFM light source never hits a flat surface at normal incidence except when it is strongly diverging or converging. A further novel feature is a three dimensional flexure to allow three dimensional motion of the optics block. Another novel feature is enabling resonant frequencies of greater than 850 Hz for two mechanical paths that most affect the performance of the AFM: the mechanical paths from the cantilever to the sample, and between the cantilever and the focusing lens. This is aided by kinematically indexing the cantilever holder directly to the top of the piezoelectric scanner to provide a direct mechanical path between the sample on top of the scanner and the cantilever. Still another novel feature, which improves both AFMs and STMs and other scanning probe microscopes, is the use of composite materials or ceramics for making housings, optics blocks, and other components of scanning probe microscopes, providing desired high stiffness and a low thermal expansion coefficient.
[0008] As a result of the use of one or more of these features, an AFM is achievable with a smaller focused spot not heretofore possible. In a particular embodiment of the invention, an improvement to an AFM is provided in which the incident beam is focused to form a spot on the cantilever having a size of 5 μm or less, preferably 3 μm or less, in at least one dimension.
[0009] Many of the improvements of this invention are applicable to optical systems broadly that measure the motion or position of a nanomechanical object, or of a nano size feature or structure of an object.
[0010] These and other aspects and advantages of the present invention will become better understood with regard to the following detailed description and accompanying drawings.
[0011]
[0012]
[0013]
[0014]
[0015]
[0016]
[0017]
[0018]
[0019]
[0020]
[0021]
[0022]
[0023]
[0024] In accordance with an embodiment of this invention, a measurement head is provided that can be used to measure the deflections of a cantilever and other nanomechanical devices and features. The most common application of this measurement head is as the detection head of an atomic force microscope, but this measurement head can also be used to make precise measurements of the motion of any nano size feature or structure or nanomechanical object, that is a feature or object where the motions on the nanometer scale are important for the operation of the device. Further, many of the principals of this measurement head can be used to provide an improved capability to measure the vertical and/or lateral motion of arbitrary objects at the nanometer scale.
[0025] These deflections are related to the force on the cantilever and can be used for measuring forces vs. distance curves, for measuring a force to be controlled by a feedback network during imaging and for the many uses that have been already established for previous atomic force microscope heads including magnetic force microscopy, Kelvin probe microscopy, non-contact AFM, and any other device for which measurements of cantilever deflection are needed.
[0026] Specifically, the invention provides one or more of the following improvements, all of which are applicable to an AFM, some to optical systems more generally, and others to scanning probe microscopes in general such as AFMs and STMs. The improvements, which are illustrated with regard to an AFM, are:
[0027] I. The incident laser beam is not aligned with the central axis of the lens
[0028] II. A small, stiff integrated optics block contains and encompasses all optical elements from the light source to the final focusing lens.
[0029] III. A flexure allows three dimensional motion of the optics block.
[0030] IV. Composite materials or ceramics are used.
[0031] V. The beam never hits a flat surface at normal incidence except when converging or diverging.
[0032] VI. The critical mechanical paths between the cantilever and the sample and between the cantilever and the focusing lens have resonant frequencies enabled greater than 850 Hz.
[0033] VII. The incident beam forms a 3 μm or less spot. This invention includes several other innovations that are described at appropriate places hereinafter.
[0034] I. The Incident Laser Beam is not Aligned with the Central Axis of the Lens.
[0035] One of the key challenges of a small cantilever AFM measurement head is the separation of the incoming and reflected light beams. The reason this is an issue is that small cantilever AFMs require high numerical aperture (NA) optics to form a small focused light spot on the cantilever. The high numerical aperture optics typically mean that a short focal length lens is placed very close to the cantilever. This leaves little space for the light beam reflected off the cantilever to pass to the detector. The previously mentioned U.S. Pat. No. 5,825,020 provides one method for separating the incoming and outgoing beams. The incoming beam is polarized, passed through the focus lens, reflected off the cantilever back through the same focus lens and then the reflected beam is directed on a separate path using a quarter wave plate.
[0036] The current invention solves this problem in a different and unique way, without the need for a quarter wave plate, as discussed below.
[0037] After leaving the collimating lens
[0038] In the preferred embodiment, as shown in
[0039] Referring back to the preferred embodiment of
[0040] II. An Integrated Optics Block.
[0041]
[0042] The integrated optics block
[0043] The integrated optics block
[0044] III. A Flexure Allows Three Dimensional Motion of the Optics Block.
[0045] The optics block
[0046] In the preferred embodiment, the disk flexure is made of steel, but it can also be made from other metals like aluminum, copper, beryllium copper, or titanium or other materials with sufficient stiffness. A vertically movable focus member
[0047] The threaded socket
[0048] A fine focus lever
[0049] Referring to
[0050] The foregoing arrangement of a vertically movable fine focus member
[0051] Referring more particularly to
[0052]
[0053] The objective lens
[0054] As shown in
[0055] The second flexure can also be eliminated in alternative embodiments. In one alternative embodiment, the collimator and light source can be arranged in an assembly fixture that allows the lens and light source to be positioned at the optimal locations to form a highly collimated exit beam and then the components can be glued in place.
[0056] IV. Composite Materials or Ceramics are Used.
[0057] The foregoing parts, as well as the unified optics block
[0058] Suitable composite materials include but are not limited to composites made from resin with high strength, high modulus fiber such as fiberglass, graphite, carbon, boron, quartz and aramid fibers, i.e. aromatic polyamide fibers characterized by excellent high temperature, flame resistance and electrical properties. Suitable composite materials are characterized by a tensile modulus of elasticity of 5 GPa to 300 GPa, which exhibit a sufficiently high thermal stability during use. In particular embodiments, the composite material has an elastic modulus of 10 GPa or higher. In a further preferred embodiment, the elastic modulus is 40 GPa or higher, and in still further preferred embodiments, the elastic modulus is 100 GPa or higher. The highest fiber strengths of the composite materials are achieved with carbon fibers. The carbon fibers may be embedded in an epoxy matrix or preferably in a graphite matrix. Orientation of the continuous fibers can be in any spatial axis, however, a semi-isotropic design in at least one plane is preferred. Some composite materials have a different thermal expansion coefficient in one axis versus the other axis. When such a material is used, it is advantageous to align the material such that the axis of lower thermal expansion is oriented along the axis of the greatest length in the mechanical path between the cantilever and the sample.
[0059] In the preferred embodiment, the inventors used a high-strength carbon-carbon composite material, consisting of carbon fibers embedded in a pyrolitic graphite matrix. The elastic modulus of carbon-carbon composites is very high, usually ranging from 15-20 GPa for composites made with 3-dimensional “fiber felt” (random orientation of fibers) to 150-20 GPa for those made with unidirectional fiber sheet. The choice of this material with a high elastic modulus-to-density ratio has a substantial impact on the ability to increase the resonant frequency of the mechanical path above 850 Hz, as described below. In addition, some carbon-carbon composite materials are available with extremely low density. For example the “Etan” material from Aerospace Composite Products has a density of 1.3 g/cm
[0060] The fiber volume content in relation to the unit of volume of the composite
[0061] material is about 20 to 70%, preferably greater than 50%. A high fiber content per unit of volume, preferably in the range of 50% to 70% has the advantage that the result is a dense material with good embedding of the hard materials leading to a high grain-strength limit.
[0062] Carbon composite materials also have a very advantageous coefficient of thermal expansion. Most scanning probe microscopes suffer from the problem of “thermal drift.” That is, the mechanical path between the probe and the sample or between the probe and the detection system changes as the temperature changes. If the mechanical path between the cantilever and sample changes length with temperature, this change appears as a change in the position of the surface of the sample, distorting any measurement made on the sample. This is a problem of thermal expansion or contraction of materials used in the mechanical path as the temperature changes. Most AFMs are made of metals like aluminum or stainless steel which have thermal expansion coefficients in the range of 10
[0063] The carbon-carbon composite of the preferred embodiment also can be directly drilled and tapped to hold the various adjustment screws used in a measurement head, for example the fine-pitch screws used to position the focused spot. The inventors have machined internal threads into the carbon-carbon composite with a pitch up to 200 threads per inch. The carbon-carbon composite material also has the property that it is somewhat self-clamping and self-lubricating. Specifically what this means is that when an adjustment screw is first turned there is a fairly strong frictional force holding it in place. Once the motion is initiated, the screw can be adjusted quite smoothly with high precision. But when the screw is left alone, the carbon-carbon composite material relaxes again and clamps down on the screw threads, holding the adjustment screw firmly in place.
[0064] The use of a composite material benefits many other components of an AFM. For example, the scanner housing
[0065] Other materials that have high stiffness and low thermal expansion coefficients, such as ceramics, would also be useful materials for scanning microscope heads. Thus fibers of the fiber structure can be made of non-oxidic, ceramic fibers, such as silicon carbide and/or silicon nitride or of fiber systems that contain silicon, boron, carbon and nitrogen.
[0066] Although the housing is shown as composed of two pieces, it can be formed of one piece or of many pieces fastened together with adhesive or fasteners, depending on ease of fabrication and other considerations. Various other three dimensional micro positioners might be used to position the unified optics block.
[0067] V. The Beam Never Hits a Flat Surface at Normal Incidence.
[0068] A novel feature of the optical system of the present invention is that the beam
[0069] VI. Critical Mechanical Paths have Resonant Frequencies Greater than 850 Hz.
[0070] Another novel feature of this microscope is a resonant frequency of the mechanical paths between the cantilever and the sample and the cantilever and the detection system greater than 850 HZ.
[0071] There is a second important mechanical path in a scanning probe microscope—the path between the cantilever (or other probe) and the detection system. This mechanical path is shown in a simplified schematic diagram in
[0072] In general, the higher the resonant frequency of these mechanical paths, the more immune the device is to external vibration. For an external noise source that is at a much lower frequency than the resonance of the structure, the noise is attenuated by the ratio (f
[0073] The current invention achieves higher resonant frequencies of these critical mechanical paths than prior art AFMs, specifically exceeding 850 Hz for one or both of the mechanical paths shown in
[0074] Using this carbon composite material, the inventors have built AFM measurement heads with resonant frequencies in excess of 850 Hz. One embodiment, built to mount in place of the “MultiMode AFM” head manufactured by Digital InstrumentsNeeco Metrology, has a mechanical resonance of approximately 1200 Hz, compared to roughly 800 Hz of the standard MultiMode AFM head. The natural frequencies of a mechanical path scale with the dimensions of the components of the path. That is, structures with smaller dimensions will have larger the natural frequencies (assuming the same material). With this in mind, the inventors have made other measurement heads much smaller than the version of the AFM head for the MultiMode AFM. For example, one embodiment of the invention has been built out of carbon composite material that has a first mechanical resonance of roughly 23 kHz.
[0075] As previously mentioned, the measurements of the resonant frequencies was confirmed using the method of the Thompson paper and/or using DesignSpace™ finite element analysis software on the Solid Edge™ computer models used to design the measurement heads.
[0076] The present invention implements an number of other improvements that also help improve the resonant frequencies of the mechanical paths. Referring to FIGS.
[0077] This arrangement gives a more direct mechanical path between the sample on top of the scanner and the cantilever, providing an increased resonant frequency, which helps to insulate the microscope from vibrations. In accordance with an embodiment of the present invention, there is thus provided the first atomic force microscope with an effective resonant frequency of vibration of cantilever relative to the sample and to the focused spot greater than 850 Hz.
[0078] This more direct path is used to incorporate an optional, removable, x-y translator that translates the cantilever holder relative to the sample to access different regions on the sample. For a further improved embodiment of the present invention, this translator could be built directly on the scanner assembly, thus eliminating a kinematic mount.
[0079] VII. The Incident Beam Forms a 5 μm or Less Spot.
[0080] In the preferred embodiment, a single element aspheric objective lens
[0081] In further embodiment of the present invention, the objective lens
[0082] The objective lens
[0083] In still another embodiment of this invention, the cantilever is moved rather than the optics block. What matters is adjustable, relative motion of the focused spot and the cantilever
[0084] Thus, the scope of the present application is not intended to be limited to the particular embodiments of the invention as described. As one of ordinary skill in the art will readily appreciate from the disclosure of the present invention, means presently existing or later to be developed that perform substantially the same function or achieve substantially the same result as means used in the embodiments described herein may be utilized according to the present invention. Accordingly, the invention is intended to include such means within its scope.